A few days ago, I got an email from Reddit advising me I have been removed as moderator of r/manhattanks. That's a violation of their policy. I haven't been inactive that long.
In recent weeks, I'm seeing ads for both Facebook and Reddit that try to sell you on the idea that if you join their platform, you can look up some niche interest of yours, find a pertinent Facebook group or event or a subreddit and immediately find your people or go to a sporting event you've never been to with insider information and have a blast -- a high quality experience where you know where to park like longtime attendees and such.
That's not how reality works.
I don't care how socially savvy you are, you join a new group of people and they need to get to know you and you need to get to know them and you have to learn the lingo and establish trust and there's a process involved. And if you don't go through that process, no, you won't go "Damn! I am HAVING A BLAST on par with longtime attendees!" because you have nothing to compare it to.
I went to a conference near Boston and drove up THROUGH New York and the drive up was awful. And I got on the phone with Valorie King because I was going to stop by her Washington DC house on the way back to Atlanta and she was like "Oh, no. Don't go through New York." and gave me instructions and the drive down was easy peasy and I appreciated it because a couple of nights earlier or whatever I was stuck in bumper to bumper traffic.
And then I got to DC and she took me out to see a few things she wanted me to see and was talking about "It's usually busier." or whatever. So I got the creme de la creme tour of DC and I had never been there before and never went back and I don't remember any of it and didn't have a sense of "Damn! I'm SO FORTUNATE!!! This is usually HOURS of standing in line like at Disney!"
It was easy. It was what SHE wanted me to see. There's no big takeaway or feeling of accomplishment or anything like that.
That's how you REALLY feel when longtime attendees successfully hand walk you through it. You feel like Genevieve felt about ME helping her: I had to PAY for it MYSELF! And I didn't even get FRIES with it!
There was no appreciation for me making sure she metaphorically got on the right bus, got off at the right stop, got walked through an alien procedure of ordering at a fast food place that she wasn't familiar with, etc. It was EASY for her and I made her do part of it herself, so I obviously did NOTHING for her!
Mark Zuckerberg once made some crack about "You FOOLS trust me!" And I remember that because I read about it while people in Aberdeen, Washington were stringing me along with saying they might still hire me and I was thinking if they hire me, I will make a similar joke about "These FOOLS hired me to play city building games with a REAL city!"
Because at the time, I didn't really feel confident I knew what I was doing.
I didn't REALLY want the job. I don't regret applying for it, but I was trying to figure out how to do certain things and I was new to town and very poor and the well-heeled buttheads in gatekeeping positions didn't REALLY want to talk to me and get to know me or let me get to know them.
They were pretending they were bedazzled with how SMART I was or something and completely skipping the part where ANYTHING social must go through that process of both sides getting to know each other and establishing trust and all those bits and pieces.
And if I am correct that the REAL problem with the town is that the Main Street America program is a Mafia organization and corrupt local gatekeepers were taking money for illegal dumping, I really would have regretted it if my half-baked plans had gotten traction.
1. If my plans to invite businesses there had worked out and THEN I concluded the downtown really should be declared a Superfund site, I would feel awful about that and have no idea how to make it right.
2. If my plans to make contacts in Alaska and send people to work seasonal jobs in canneries had worked out and THEN I concluded the downtown should really be declared a Superfund site, I would be horrified and have no idea how to fix it.
Mark Zuckerberg was YOUNG when Facebook got traction and he's relatively young still for a self-made billionaire and NOW all that matters to him is keeping the money rolling in and he doesn't live like ordinary people and may not really know these ads are BULLSHIT and reality doesn't work that way.
And may not REALLY care, because what matters is he needs MORE people adding to his bottom line for some damn reason.
Not everyone does that.
The woman who founded French Rags ran the business for some years and eventually shut it down.
Historically, some guy in American history who was wealthy had a failed business deal or whatever and repaid everyone out of pocket, putting an end to his wealth. I think the Mayflower Madame, Sidney Biddle Barrows, is his descendant and she grew up with heirloom furniture in a family struggling to get by financially.
Arguably, I don't have more money in part because I have been trying to figure out HOW you DO certain things.
I wondered HOW you establish a reputation and trust and all that in the world of business. I spent years on Hacker News trying to figure out how male movers and shakers actually get stuff done and I have a lot of criticisms of women who just want to scream about sexism and how they deserve as much MONEY as men "for the SAME job" or whatever.
I had a corporate job. I was cleaning up the messes of people the company was rewarding for playing by the rules and being FASTER than ME. I have absolutely no reason to believe two people with the same job title are actually contributing equally and every reason to believe that is almost never the case and I think a lot of women don't actually understand what the job is really about.
I remember trying to invite women to Hacker News or something like that and thinking I could move the numbers because I'm a woman with relatively high karma and I can open doors for women or something and I look back on that absolutely MORTIFIED and going "No wonder they don't WANT ninnies like me!"
If the most important thing to you is someone's gender, you are doing it wrong.
Our world is in crisis GLOBALLY and I think part of the reason for that is women's lib means we have fewer MEN qualified to do essential jobs and most women don't get it AT ALL and just want THE PAYCHECK.
I have been interested in trying to figure out what's under the hood and how you make the economic engine run in a healthy fashion if you deconstruct heteronormative culture and do something else.
And I didn't even have the WORDS for that when I started.
I don't know what big city planners do. I do know that the Federal government has standards for checking environmental stuff for certain things before you are allowed to proceed and it's quite challenging to meet a standard of actually safe to drink water with approachable DIY instructions on the Internet, which is part of what I write about.
In some sense, I don't really CARE that I "failed" in Aberdeen, Washington -- that I didn't get the job and didn't get my half-baked plans implemented etc.
I no longer feel like "You FOOLS! Hiring me to play city building games with a REAL city!" I feel comfortable with my WRITING about rural and small town development.
I still probably don't want and never REALLY wanted the job I applied for or one like it. I was NEW to town and wasn't BEING introduced to people and inculcated into the local social fabric.
My writing meets a certain standard and let's people know that it's your responsibility to be familiar with local conditions on the ground and pick and choose appropriate solutions from the stuff I make available.
I'm happy with that.
Reddit tends to have active subs for bigger cities but not for small communities. I never really made headway on changing that. I don't know why, but I don't think they are ethical -- see my opening paragraph -- and in practice the theory that the Internet is for everyone and levels the playing field doesn't work. The Internet empowers big players to shaft the little people and rural and small town people tend to not really want to play this game or it doesn't work for them or whatever.
Facebook has a long, ugly track record of causing extremely horrible problems when it goes into other countries and often doesn't bother to hire moderators fluent in the local language. Facebook has absolutely no respect whatsoever for social entities or the people that make up social anything and is entirely about lining Mark Zuckerberg's pockets and massaging his ego.
I don't know what we should do about this, but social media as it currently exists is, in practice, a cancer eating the world and I am not for continuing with the status quo and I am not currently active on any social media. I blog and post it to Patreon and that's it.
Comments
Post a Comment